|
THE STRETCHER- BEARER
TRADITION |
 |
Stretcher-bearers
struggling through mud during the Third Battle of Ypres, August
1917
IWM
Q 5939 |
By C. E. W. BEAN, Australian Historian
of WW1
including the
Simpson and his donkey story.
I wonder how many of our
old First and Fifth Divisions remember the capture, on the second day of
the Battle of Amiens, 9 August 19 18, of a big system of dugouts in the
pasture just beyond Harbonnieres. The dugouts had originally been British,
but since the German thrust in March of that year they had been used as a
German divisional headquarters. In our great push of 8 August they lay
just beyond the objective, but were almost overrun by a whippet tank and
cavalry.
 |
20 August 1916 Pozieres.
Bearers of the 6th Bde pass the old cemetery on their return from
Moquet farm. The leader carries a Red Cross flag. Artillery shells
cannot see Red Cross flags. |
A scratch headquarters
guard of 500 men shot the tank to flames and captured or killed the brave
British crew under Lieutenant D. Arnold and so allowed the staffs of three
German divisions to escape; and with hurried reinforcements the dugouts
were stubbornly held next day when-temporarily without artillery or tank
support-our 15th and, later, 2nd Brigades attacked.
 |
WW1 Stretcher Bearers
light canvas arm band with red cross. |
A German account says
that the British aeroplanes before the attack flew so low that the
garrison thought they would touch the ground. Some pilots, it is said,
shouted "Surrender" and one threw out a note but he was shot
down in flames. In desperate fighting Lieutenant Vialon of the 26th
(German) Reserve Infantry Regiment thought that he had held the Australian
infantry in front, and, "proud and cheerful", as he himself
writes, he ran to his right flank group.
I arrive at the precise
moment when the Australians with bombs and fixed bayonets force their way
into the trench." They had come from the rear! He was instantly
clubbed. Amid shouts of "Hands up!" he scrambled to his feet and
knocked down "with a boxing punch" the two first men he met, but
then felt a tremendous blow on the upper thigh. He crawled to a rifle-pit
and lay there. The attack passed on. 
Half an hour later
another wave of Australians came through. Vialon says he was roughly
handled by them until they realized that he was wounded. On recovering
from the worst fright and pain he lit the stump of a cigar. He writes:
"To see this, to rip the stump from my mouth and throw it away, was-
for an Australian who strolled up from the rear- the work of an instant.
Then he groped in his greatcoat pocket, drew from it a big tin box, and
showered me about twenty cigarettes in one shot.
This same man called up
a stretcher-bearer and the two with their united strength bandaged me
well, so that the loss of blood stopped." These stretcher-bearers
carried him to Harbonnieres village where he rejoined his captured
comrades and they "took their best pains to make our position easier
for us".
Another German who
stressed the kindness and "sportsmanship" of Australian stretcher-bearers
and others, in and on the way to hospital, was the dying airman, Prince
Frederick Charles of Prussia, shot down near Lagnicourt in France in March
1917. He, too, was a sport, he said.
In the A.I.F. the body
of men whom these opponents appreciated had won a quite outstanding
reputation. I remember clearly the days at Anzac when it was made. In the
first recruiting of the A.I.F. everyone had looked on the work of
stretcher-bearers as rather suitable for men who, for some reason,
disliked more than most the prospect of killing others. It may seem rather
an absurd assumption nowadays, but we knew little of war; and I dare say
that in the long run a good many of those who did become
stretcher-bearers, even regimental ones, did volunteer for it because they
were that kind of man, who deep in their hearts preferred being killed to
killing (though they certainly wouldn't talk of their opinion) and that it
had a good deal to do with their reputation. 
At all events, although
a good many boys of tender upbringing and high education did enlist in the
original field ambulances as stretcher-bearers, while men outwardly
indistinguishable from the rest of the Australian infantry and light horse
volunteered or were picked as the regimental bearers, no one in the A.I.F.
could distinguish the performance of these two classes. The reason
certainly was that the stretcher-bearers, ambulance and regimental, were
determined that, come what might, they would show themselves as ready to
stake their lives on doing their job as were any fighting men.
They showed this from
the first hours of the Landing at Anzac. In the battle which that day
flowed over the ridges, where the low holly-oak scrub gave cover from
height only about knee high, many companies had every stretcher-bearer
killed or wounded. Wherever a wounded man was seen in the scrub or a cry
went up for bearers, these men made their way, whatever the danger.
Corporal J. B. Malone of the 3rd Battalion's medical detachment, hopping
from shelter to shelter on MacLaurin's Hill, had three bullets through his
cap, one through puttee and boot, and one through his coat, and others
ripped the bottom from a bucket that he carried. He survived though most
who tried similar tasks never came back.
Three years later, when
some of us revisited Gallipoli and searched the ridges to which our most
advanced line managed to cling for part of that day, there. on the
southern shoulder of Baby 700, far beyond the line afterwards held by our
troops we found the tom remains of a field medical pannier such as our
medical detachments then carried. Hardly one stretcher-bearer returned
from that part of the fight.
That day they built the
tradition that still worked in the Second A.I.F. I remember just after the
arrival of a salvo of Turkish shrapnel on an exposed crest, hearing the
call "stretcher bearers" nearby, and then seeing two men stroll
down, one with stretcher on shoulder and pipe in mouth, walking full
height when everyone else crouched in shelter from the next salvo or
dashed from cover to cover. As the two passed every man watched and
respected them. Such things happened everywhere. High up on Walker's Ridge
on our left flank, overlooking North Beach, Australians and New Zealanders
gazed down on three or four stranded boats that had come ashore far beyond
the flank and had been shot to pieces by Turks on the heights nearby. Next
day it was seen that some men in the boats, previously believed to be
dead, had changed their position. It seemed clear that some were still
living. At intervals all that day, men on the warships and infantry
on the heights saw stretcher-bearers, principally two of the 2nd Battalion
(S. F. Carpenter and E. A. Roberts) make that dangerous journey along the
beach to the boats and back with bullets kicking the sand about them.
Two bearers were seen to
fall and lie there with their stretcher; nine wounded men are said to have
been brought in.
Simpson
and his Donkey 
 |
The regimental bearers had
raised the reputation of their comrades sky-high within two days of the
A.I.F. going into action. But, as chance had it. it was an ambulance
bearer whose name will always be most prominently associated with the
saving of life at Anzac.
A ship's fireman of Melbourne (a north of England
man by birth), John Simpson Kirkpatrick, who had enlisted in the 3rd Field
Ambulance as "Simpson", constantly carried wounded down the
valley which formed the approach to most of the Anzac front, and of which
the lower course received its name from the shrapnel that then regularly
burst along it. |
In the valley were wandering
some donkeys, which had been landed with the troops for water-carriage but
had not been so used, the Greek drivers being mistrusted in the spy-scare
that followed the stopping of our advance. It occurred to Simpson that a donkey would
be the most comfortable mode of transport for men wounded in the leg. He
therefore caught one and every day, and well into each night, brought down
on it wounded from the head of the valley. The sight of him, with his arm
round the wounded man, and the donkey picking its way down the valley-bed,
became famous throughout Anzac. Men called him "Scotty" or
"Murphy" and his donkey "Duffy".
The shrapnel and sniping
down the valley never stopped him; and the ambulance commander,
recognizing the value of his work, allowed him to carry it on almost as a
separate unit. He bivouacked with his donkey at the Indian mule camp
beside the valley. To double his efficiency he annexed a second donkey-.
His work continued until
the great Turkish attack on 19 May when Anzac was shelled with more guns
and more ammunition. He usually called for breakfast at the water-guard
over the well in the valley. This morning breakfast was not ready, but he
said cheerily: "Never mind. Get me a good dinner when I come
back." He did not come back.
As he was returning with
two patients a burst of shrapnel pierced his heart, and wounded anew each
of his patients. That quiet bravery was one of the stretcher-bearer's
regular attributes. 
It was perhaps never
seen more clearly than in another ambulance bearer, G. T. Hill, in private
life an accountant and captain of a swimming club. He and another bearer
were carrying a patient round the exposed slope of Hell Spit at the
southern end of the Beach when a shrapnel shell burst above them and the
pellets spattered the earth around them.
One bearer was seen by
watchers on the Beach to stumble, but the two carried on and presently
deposited their patient beside the others at the casualty clearing station
by the shore. Hill walked to a heap of stretchers and quietly sat there.
Presently he fell over. They found that a pellet had pierced his
breast-bone. He died before he could be taken to the hospital ship.
The tradition of
stretcher-bearers established at the Landing at Anzac was outstanding,
yet, as the great historian of the Australian Medical Services, Colonel
Graham Butler, says, "the moral status . . . of the regimental
bearers steadily rose during the war". Until
the First Battle of the Somme many battalions had used their bandsmen as
stretcher-bearers. After that battle this system generally was abandoned. For
one thing after such battles the band was too badly needed for cheering up
the troops! A battle like Pozieres sometimes made a clean sweep of the
regimental bearers. Also, on its side, the work of the bearers was too
important to be left to unselected men; they were now specially selected
"for their physique and guts".
They needed both
to stand up to a trial like that of Pozieres and the terrible winter that
followed it. On Pozières crest, a reeking desert of bombarded shell
craters, the stretcher-bearers and runners were the only ones who were
regularly expected to move through the barrages which, after each of
twenty successive fights, cut off the front line from the rear. Most men
who went through that battle will recall the little parties of four or
five men with a stretcher who would come, erect, winding their way across
that wilderness, amid the shell bursts, with the leader holding a stick
with a white rag-the handiest substitute for a red cross flag. 
| "Don’t forget
me, cobber". The
sight of the wounded lying helpless within a stone’s throw from safety
so affected Major A W Murdoch of the 29th Battalion that
he improvised a flag of truce, crossed no-man’s land to the German lines and asked a
German Lieutenant if an informal truce could be declared so
the wounded could be rescued. The German
officer received permission from his HQ for the truce but Murdoch was told
that the Allied General HQ had given orders that "no negotiations of
any kind, and on any subject, were to be had with the enemy".
So the Australian stretcher bearers were stopped from going out. Bean
wrote: "Then was seen along the whole front of the Australian 5th
Division that magnificent tribute of devotion which the Australian soldier
never failed to pay to his mates. "For three days and nights, risking
death or wounding, single men and parties continued to go out to help the
wounded. On the night of July 20, 300 men
were rescued. One
of those who went to help was Lieutenant (then Sergeant) Fraser.
He found
one man who was too heavy for him to lift on his own. He was just about to
go back for a stretcher party when another man called out from 30 metres
away: "Don’t forget me, cobber". Fraser and his stretcher
parties rescued both men. Fraser was killed a year later at the second
battle of Bullecourt and has no known grave. 
|
That flag would usually
prevent the German snipers from shooting, but nothing could stop the
barrages, even when, as often at Bullecourt, the artillery observers must
plainly have seen that the traffic at the moment was that of stretcher
bearers. At the Anzac Landing a big stretcher bearer, T. Blackburn,
Lancashire-born, had said to his mates in a hot burst of shelling:
"It's no good dropping the stretcher now-if we're going to be hit we
shall be bit, walking or crouching!" So they went proudly erect at Pozieres,
Passchendaele and Messines too, throughout the war.
And the Light Horse
stretcher-bearers charged mounted with their regiments at Beersheba in
Palestine. As Colonel Butler reminds us, the bearers had important medical
functions besides the prompt carriage of the wounded for the earliest
possible treatment. Theirs were the first measures to prevent or alleviate
shock. It was in coolly going about his work when the charging Light Horse
swept over the Turkish trenches and dismounted men were still fighting
about the earthworks, that "Tlbby" Cotter, the famous fast
bowler, was shot by a Turk at close range.
You won't find our
stretcher-bearers of 1914-18 among the Victoria Cross winners, though
there are many among the D.C.Ms (whom I, for one, hold every bit as high).
After some magnificent work by A. L. Carson, J. Paul and others at
Bullecourt, the reason why no Victoria Crosses were given for medical
service became clear-some high authority had
misunderstood a ruling in the matter. The
mistake continued through the war. But I think that, on the whole, the
stretcher-bearers won the award they would most have coveted -the highest
place in the estimate of all their comrades.  |